The Good
- Fantastic cast of characters.
- Blackbeard
- Edward is a very strong protagonist.
- Fluid combat.
- Streamlined naval combat.
- Vast open-world.
- Strong and very emotional story.
- Fun puzzle-oriented Present-Time gameplay.
- Desmond files.
The Bad
- Meaningless Collectibles.
- Upgrading is a grind.
- Flat Present-day characters.
- Too many “Tail” and “Eavesdrop” objectives.